Home / Guidelines & Products

Q5E – Comparability of Biotechnological/Biological Products Subject to Changes in their Manufacturing Process

Guideline number: Q5E
Status: Implementation (Step 5)
Adopted (Step 4): 18 November 2004

The ICH Harmonised Guideline was finalised under Step 4 in November 2004.

The objective of this document is to provide principles for assessing the comparability of biotechnological/biological products before and after changes are made in the manufacturing process for the drug substance or drug product.

Therefore, this Guideline is intended to assist in the collection of relevant technical information which serves as evidence that the manufacturing process changes will not have an adverse impact on the quality, safety and efficacy of the drug product.

The document does not prescribe any particular analytical, nonclinical or clinical strategy. The main emphasis of the document is on quality aspects.

The ICH Harmonised Guideline was finalised under Step 4 in July 1997. This document covers the preclinical safety testing requirements for biotechnological products. It addresses the use of animal models of disease, determination of when genotoxicity assays and carcinogenicity studies should be performed, and the impact of antibody formation on duration of toxicology studies.

An addendum was proposed to provide clarification on S6 and an update of the following topics discussed in the original ICH S6 Guideline: species selection, study design, immunogenicity, reproductive and developmental toxicity and assessment of carcinogenic potential. The Harmonised addendum provides further complementary guidance to the S6 Guideline and helps to define the current recommendations and reduce the likelihood that substantial differences will exist among regions.

The addendum reached Step 4 of the harmonisation process in June 2011 and was integrated as part II in the core Guideline that was then renamed S6(R1).

Guideline

Annexes

Annexes

Guideline implementation

ANMAT, Argentina

-

In the process of implementation;
ANVISA, Brazil

-

Implemented; Date: 4 January 2021; Reference: RDC 413/2020
COFEPRIS, Mexico

-

In the process of implementation; Date: 20 September 2013; Reference: Mexican Official Standard NOM-177-SSA1-2013
EC, Europe

-

Implemented; Date: 1 June 2005; Reference: CPMP/ICH/5721/03
EDA, Egypt

-

Implemented; Date: 31 December 2013; Reference: Regulatory guide for mechanisms, procedures and rules of implementing the decree of Egyptian Drug Authority No.343 of 2021
FDA, United States

-

Implemented; Date: 1 June 2005; Reference: Vol. 70, No. 125, p. 37861-2
HSA, Singapore

-

Implemented; Date: 1 January 2008;
Health Canada, Canada

-

Implemented; Date: 15 June 2015; Reference: File #: 15-107053-353
JFDA, Jordan

-

Implemented; Date: 2 January 2016;
MFDS, Republic of Korea

-

Implemented; Date: 1 June 2009; Reference: Guidelines on comparability of biological products after change in the manufacturing process [Guideline-0316-01]
MHLW/PMDA, Japan

-

Implemented; Date: 1 April 2005; Reference: PFSB/ELD Notification No. 0426001
MHRA, UK

-

Implemented; Date: 4 December 1995;
NAFDAC, Nigeria

-

Not yet implemented;
NMPA, China

-

Implemented; Date: 21 July 2020; Reference: NMPA, China Announcement No. 7 (2020)
SAHPRA, South Africa

-

In the process of implementation;
SFDA, Saudi Arabia

-

Implemented; Date: 22 August 2017;
Swissmedic, Switzerland

-

Implemented; Date: 18 November 2004; Reference: ICH Guidelines apply in Switzerland automatically upon reaching Step 4: Swissmedic Journal 05/2006, p. 504
TFDA, Chinese Taipei

-

Implemented; Date: 22 December 2014; Reference: Public Announcement for ” List for ICH Guidelines Adopted.”
TITCK, Türkiye

-

Implemented; Date: 11 December 2021; Reference: Regulation on the Marketing Authorization of Medicinal Products for Human Use and Guidelines on the Development and Registration of Biosimilar Medicinal Products

Q+A

Q+A Status: Implementation (Step 5)